Restricting reported orders & the expectation of privacy in the employment tribunals

16 November 2026

This case in the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) considered the extent to which a temporary restricted reporting order (RRO) could be made permanent following judgment in the case. 

MC v Ms G concerned allegations of sexual harassment, sex-related harassment and victimisation. Ms G had worked for a small company whose sole director MC had exchanged sexual messages with her, mainly via Snapchat, between 2015 and 2019. 

The tribunal made a restricted reporting order for the duration of the hearing and until judgment had been given because the claim involved allegations of sexual misconduct.

In the event the claims failed with the tribunal finding that the messages had been consensual. 

Privacy and restrictions on disclosure in employment tribunal litigation are covered by rule 49 of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2013. The tribunal must give full weight to the principle of open justice and to the Convention right to freedom of expression. 

The tribunal refused to grant a permanent RRO.

MC appealed to the EAT arguing on several grounds that the decision was wrong.

The EAT held that the decision of the tribunal was indeed incorrect. Among other things the tribunal had failed to consider whether the respondent’s reasonable expectation of privacy in respect of the messages, which the tribunal agreed had been consensual and made a derogation from open justice necessary.

The EAT accepted that MC was entitled to rely on a legitimate expectation of privacy in sexual activity. Where a legitimate expectation of privacy exists and in particular in relation to consensual sexual activity this is a highly significant factor that must be considered. Whether the case was likely to attract press interest was not a relevant consideration: the relevant question was whether interference with the reasonable expectation of privacy was justified. 

RROs and anonymity orders are increasingly sought by parties in employment tribunal litigation for a variety of reasons and in particular in relation to sexual harassment and whistleblowing claims. Tribunals will consider applications on their own facts and merits. Tribunals may also of their own initiative make orders so far as they consider necessary in the interests of justice or in order to protection the human rights of parties. 

The general rule is that justice must be done openly and any derogation from this rule will be carefully considered on its facts. 

Yavnik Ganguly

Written by Yavnik Ganguly

Senior Solicitor

Yavnik is an employment solicitor with experience advising employees and workers on a wide range of workplace disputes. Having trained at Bindmans after starting his career at Leigh Day, he has particular expertise in discrimination claims and is committed to helping clients assert their rights and secure fair outcomes with clear, practical advice.

Read more about Yavnik

what our clients say

Write A Review

we are never far away, providing nationwide coverage.

As a nationwide employment law firm, we act for employees across the UK in employment discrimination cases. Contact us today to book your telephone assessment.

Book Your FREE Consultation

Contact Us