In a letter circulated by the President of the Employment Tribunals (Scotland) Judge Susan Walker has announced the employment tribunals in Scotland will stop listing case management hearings as a matter of course for discrimination and whistleblowing claims. This applies whether the claimant is legally represented or not. For now the change impacts only the tribunals in Scotland but it is to hoped that England and Wales might adopt the same approach.
Case management hearings are listed in order to prepare claims for trial. They deal with setting the parameters of what the tribunal will be asked to determine in a claim and they set the timetable. Preparations for these hearings include agreeing a list of issues in the claim, agreeing dates when key steps in the tribunal process must take place by, stating dates to avoid listing a final hearing due to unavailability of parties or experts and so on. Much of the preparation can be done in writing through emails between the parties. Legal representatives on either side of the claim often turn up to case management hearings with this work already done and agreed, leaving the judge only to sanction what has been agreed and issue orders. Sometimes matters are more complicated for a variety of reasons but those could still be dealt with by listing a short case management hearing.
The aim of the changes in Scotland is to make best use of limited court time and judges. This seems sensible. This could also significantly speed up the time it takes to get a full hearing listed and remove some of the very significant delays currently in the system.
Judge Walker notes that this change places additional burden on representatives but this is work many of us do already anyway as a matter of course before a case management hearing. For litigants in person it perhaps imposes a greater burden but there is a wealth of information online to assist in the preparation and respondent representatives in claims faced with dealing with a litigant in person would do well to remember their duty to assist unrepresented parties.
Judge Walker’s letter notes the burden but the benefits to those wishing to have claims heard seem quite obvious. The process may be quicker:
“We do appreciate that this can place an additional burden on representatives and we are grateful for your assistance. We hope users will agree that these changes are a pragmatic and reasonable response to the challenges that the system is facing and to ensure that case get to a final hearing within a reasonable time.”
